CO2 Laser vs. Erbium: Which Laser Resurfacing Is Right for You?

If you searched "CO2 laser near me" and ended up here, good. CO2 is the laser everyone has heard of. It's been the go-to for resurfacing since the 1990s, and it works.

But when I was choosing a laser for my practice, I didn't choose CO2. I chose erbium, on the Sciton Joule. I think about every treatment the same way: what's the best result I can get with the least risk to the patient? For most people who walk in asking for CO2, erbium is what I'd pick for them.

Here's how they compare, and why I went with erbium.

What CO2 and erbium lasers actually do

Both are ablative lasers. That means they remove thin layers of damaged skin so your body can rebuild fresh, smoother skin with new collagen underneath. Both can soften wrinkles and clean up sun damage and scarring.

Where they differ is water.

Your skin is mostly water, and both lasers work by targeting it. The CO2 laser works at a wavelength of 10,600 nm. The erbium laser works at 2,940 nm, which water absorbs many times more readily. So erbium vaporizes the targeted skin cleanly and precisely, and very little heat spreads into the skin around it. CO2 sends more heat into the surrounding tissue.

That heat is part of why CO2 can tighten skin so dramatically. It's also why CO2 patients usually heal slower and are more likely to deal with redness or pigment changes that stick around.

There's research behind this. In a well-known split-face study published in the Archives of Dermatology, patients had CO2 on one side of the face and erbium on the other. The heat damage left behind on the erbium side measured up to 50 microns, compared with up to 200 microns on the CO2 side. Redness at 2 weeks showed up in 67% of erbium sides versus 95% of CO2 sides, and loss of pigment showed up in 5% of erbium sides versus 43% of CO2 sides.

The researchers concluded that erbium was safe and effective and that patients recovered faster. (source)

CO2 vs. erbium at a glance

Erbium (Sciton Joule)CO2
Wavelength2,940 nm10,600 nm
Heat to surrounding skinMinimalSignificant
Typical downtimeA few days to about 1 week, depending on depthOften 2 weeks or more
Lingering rednessShorterCan last weeks to months
Risk of pigment changesLowerHigher, especially in medium and darker skin
AdjustabilityFine-tuned from a light peel to deep resurfacingMostly built for deeper treatments
Best forFine lines, texture, sun damage, acne scars, deeper wrinkles in a seriesDeep wrinkles and laxity in lighter skin types who can take the recovery

Why I chose erbium for Inside Out

I spent 18 years in the emergency department, and I still practice like it. I want results you can see, and I want to control exactly what the laser is doing.

The Sciton Joule erbium platform gives me that control. I can set the depth for your skin, your concerns, and your calendar, and I can adjust from one area of the face to the next. Around the eyes and on the neck, where skin is thinner, that precision matters.

It also means I can offer a range of treatments from one platform instead of a one-size-fits-all laser:

  • Micro Laser Peel: a lighter erbium resurfacing for dull skin, fine lines, and uneven texture.
  • Halo: a hybrid fractional laser that pairs erbium with a second, non-ablative wavelength. You get resurfacing and a glow with downtime matched to your schedule.
  • Contour TRL: full erbium resurfacing for deeper wrinkles, acne scarring, and significant sun damage. This is the treatment most comparable to CO2.

If you came here looking for CO2 because you want a dramatic result, Contour TRL is where we start that conversation. Many patients reach results similar to CO2 through a treatment plan that may include more than 1 session, with a faster recovery each time. You can compare all of my laser treatments in one place.

When CO2 can still make sense

I'd rather tell you the truth than sell you something. CO2 is a powerful laser. In that same split-face study, the CO2 side showed somewhat more wrinkle improvement overall, though patients who had more erbium passes saw results that weren't significantly different.

CO2 can be a reasonable choice if you have very deep wrinkles or loose skin, fair skin, and the time to take 2 weeks or more away from work and social plans. If that's you, I'll talk you through it at your consultation and point you in the right direction.

For most of the people I see, erbium makes more sense. You still get real resurfacing. You just heal faster, with less chance of side effects that hang around for months.

Common questions

Do you offer CO2 laser in Fort Collins or Timnath?

No. I offer erbium laser resurfacing on the Sciton Joule, including Contour TRL, Halo, and Micro Laser Peel. For most patients looking for CO2 results, these treatments get there with less heat and a faster recovery.

Is erbium the same as a CO2 laser?

No. Both are ablative resurfacing lasers, but they use different wavelengths. Erbium is absorbed more efficiently by the water in your skin, so it sends far less heat into surrounding tissue.

Is erbium safer than CO2 for darker skin?

Erbium generally carries a lower risk of pigment changes than CO2, which is why it's often preferred for medium and olive skin tones. Every skin type still needs a careful plan, and I'll review your history before recommending any laser.

How long is the downtime?

It depends on the depth. A Micro Laser Peel can mean a few days of redness and flaking. Deeper Contour TRL resurfacing takes longer, usually about a week before you feel ready to be seen. We'll set the depth around your calendar.

Is Halo a CO2 laser?

No. Halo is a hybrid fractional laser that combines erbium with a non-ablative wavelength. It's a great middle ground for texture, tone, and fine lines.

How many treatments will I need?

Some patients see what they want after 1 treatment. Others do better with a series. You'll leave your consultation knowing your plan and what to expect.

Not sure which one is right for you?

You don't need to figure this out from Google. Come in, tell me what's bothering you about your skin and how much downtime you can live with, and I'll tell you what I'd do if you were my sister. Sometimes that's laser. Sometimes it isn't.

Book a consultation or call 970-637-4342. Inside Out serves Fort Collins, Timnath, Windsor, Loveland, and Greeley.

This post is for education only and isn't medical advice. Talk with a licensed provider about what's right for your skin.

Sources

Start with a consultation

Ready to feel like yourself again?

Book a consultation with Mollie. You'll leave with a clear plan for your skin and your goals. There's no pressure to commit.